Karen Malina White

Shirley Hughes

5 ep

Scott Paophavihanh

Anouke Sinthasomphone

5 ep

Somlit Inthalangsy

Sayamone Sinthasomphone

4 ep

Shaun Brown

Tracy Edwards

3 ep

Penelope Ann Miller

Joyce Dahmer

3 ep

Kieran Tamondong

Konerak Sinthasomphone

3 ep

Matthew Alan

Officer Gabrish

3 ep

Scott Michael Morgan

Officer Balcerzak

3 ep

Rodney Burford

Tony Hughes

3 ep

Dia La Ren Nash

Sandra Smith

3 ep

Dyllón Burnside

Ronald Flowers

3 ep

DaShawn Barnes

Rita Isbell

3 ep

Nikea Gamby-Turner

Mildred Lindsey

3 ep

David Barrera

Chief Arreola

3 ep

Mac Brandt

Robert Rauth

2 ep

Grant Harvey

Rolf Mueller

2 ep

Josh Braaten

Young Lionel Dahmer

2 ep

Cameron Cowperthwaite

Steven Hicks

2 ep

Nigel Gibbs

Reverend Jesse Jackson

2 ep

Savannah Brown

Young Joyce Dahmer

2 ep

Chris Gann

Police Officer #1

2 ep

Mark Reininga

Young Police Officer

2 ep

Leanne Suter

On Camera Reporter

2 ep

Ken Clement

Wally the Butcher

2 ep

Amy Mack

Barbara Hughes

2 ep

Corey Timmons

Will Hughes

2 ep

Kyrsten V. Williams

Kim Hughes

2 ep

Maurice Demus

Jacob

2 ep

Clark Moore

Deputy Chief

2 ep

Raymond Watanga

Sopa Princewill

2 ep

Rodney J. Hobbs

African American Sergeant

2 ep

Keyla McNeely

Dorothy Straughter

2 ep

Jake Green

Officer Kelly

2 ep

Furly Mac

Christopher Scarver

2 ep

Brey Chanadet

Other Kid

1 ep

Nick Fisher

Young Jeffrey Dahmer

1 ep

Justin Stella

Derek

1 ep

Andy Taylor Kim

Investigator

1 ep

Ken Lerner

Joe Zilber

1 ep

Michael Andrew Baker

Lionel's Lawyer

1 ep

Jesse Bush

Officer #1

1 ep

Thomas Crawford

Judge

1 ep

Colin Ford

Chazz

1 ep

Karole Foreman

Dottie

1 ep

Asa Germann

Blonde Jogger

1 ep

Matthew Gilmore

Officer #2

1 ep

Trilby Glover

Guidance Counselor

1 ep

Alex Hyde-White

Doctor

1 ep

Emma Kennedy

Denise

1 ep

Peter MacKenzie

Mr. Bertoglio

1 ep

Tenz McCall

Young David Dahmer

1 ep

David Theune

Math Teacher

1 ep

Ato Blankson-Wood

Aaron

1 ep

Rhoyle Ivy King

Don

1 ep

Joshua Edward Moore

CSI Investigator

1 ep

Hope Banks

Mrs. Hempsill

1 ep

Cole Capps

Kevin

1 ep

Tyler Crim

Paramedic #2

1 ep

Tempany Deckert

Front Desk Police Officer

1 ep

Peter Holden

Police Officer

1 ep

Daniel Curtis Lee

Police Photographer

1 ep

Keylor Leigh

Department Store Clerk

1 ep

Travon McCall

Police Lieutenant

1 ep

Curtis Nelson II

Paramedic #1

1 ep

Teshi Thomas

Nicole Childress

1 ep

Vince Hill-Bedford

Steven Tuomi

1 ep

Blake Cooper Griffin

Charles

1 ep

Mark Atteberry

Dr. Park Dietz - Psychologist

1 ep

Hollie Bahar

Field Surgeon

1 ep

Fiona Bishop

Yearbook Girl

1 ep

Aaron Coleman

Dean of Students

1 ep

Bill Doyle

Special Agent

1 ep

Brie Eley

Clinician

1 ep

Isaac Faulkner

Dan

1 ep

Michael Germant

Seth

1 ep

Brittany Giles

Tina

1 ep

Steve Hasley

Photographer

1 ep

John Ahle Kellar

Doug Brozovsky

1 ep

Eugene Ko

Yearbook Guy

1 ep

Teddy Margas

Sticky Ricky

1 ep

Collie Jay Simmons

Bartender

1 ep

Carson Zone

Tanner

1 ep

Benjahmin Svyatoslavich

Anthony Sears

1 ep

Matt Cordova

Detective Rauss

1 ep

Jamela Asha

Stenographer

1 ep

Skyler Bible

Richard Guerrero

1 ep

Ivar Brogger

Judge

1 ep

Ron Bush

Jeffery’s Lawyer

1 ep

Crystal Coney

Nurse

1 ep

Samjai Daniels

James Doxator

1 ep

Lacy Diamond

Prisoner #1

1 ep

Dion LaMarr Harvey

Prisoner #2

1 ep

Ken Ivy

African American Man

1 ep

Ben Scott

Bus Driver

1 ep

Mark Weiler

Officer

1 ep

Nikyla Boxley

Young Shirley Hughes

1 ep

Karl Makinen

Officer Clyde Reynolds

1 ep

Noel Arthur

Doctor

1 ep

Olivia Baptista

Margaret

1 ep

Bruce Beatty

Dr. Larry Weeks

1 ep

Christopher Bencomo

Manny

1 ep

Anissa Borrego

Cashier

1 ep

Jared DeBusk

Rico

1 ep

Jordan Michael Green

Hairstylist

1 ep

Cheryl Francis Harrington

Shirley’s Mother

1 ep

Taneka Johnson

Pediatrics Nurse

1 ep

Caroline Klidonas

Makeup Artist

1 ep

Eva La Dare

Delivery Nurse

1 ep

Brandon Papo

Male Employee

1 ep

Arthur Richardson

Manager

1 ep

John Shartzer

Marcus

1 ep

Michael Anthony Spady

Rufus

1 ep

Matt Steele

Duane

1 ep

Keanush Tafreshi

Denim Employee #1

1 ep

Brandon Black

Dean Vaughn

1 ep

Raphael Sbarge

Mayor John Norquist

1 ep

Jacob Chattman

Paul Myers

1 ep

Stephanie Erb

Susan

1 ep

Scott Thomas Reynolds

Police Officer #2

1 ep

Dieu Tran

Nousone Sinthasomphone

1 ep

Jacob Zukowski

Joseph Bradehoft

1 ep

Tom Virtue

Father Hecker

1 ep

Ava Ticotin

Janie Hagen

1 ep

Rosemary Thomas

Catherine Straughter

1 ep

Spencer Squire

Nick

1 ep

Tony Robinette

Donald Bradehoft

1 ep

Jordan Wall

Darryl

1 ep

Jonathan Stanley

Officer Krause

1 ep

Onh S. Phabmixay

Elder Woman

1 ep

Paul Zies

Tattooed Prisoner

1 ep

Jim McCaffree

Sheriff - 1957

1 ep

Eric Normington

Gavin

1 ep

Michael Adler

Judge Lawrence Gram

1 ep

Carlos Arellano

Bailiff

1 ep

Molly Baker

Audience Member

1 ep

Serene Branson

News Correspondent

1 ep

Markina Brown

Fresno Reporter #2

1 ep

Demián Castro

Geraldo Rivera

1 ep

Chase Fein

Police Officer #2

1 ep

Vanessa Giordano

Fresno Reporter #1

1 ep

Horace Gold

Isaac Richards

1 ep

Arye Gross

Gerald Boyle

1 ep

Bobbie Lee Jr.

J.W. Smith

1 ep

Shane Kerwin

Ed Gein

1 ep

Ericka Kreutz

Female Sergeant

1 ep

Mercy Malick

Milwaukee Reporter #2

1 ep

Ed Mattiuzzi

Milwaukee Reporter #3

1 ep

Danny Max

Fresno Reporter #3

1 ep

Phil Biedron

Portage Prison Guard

1 ep

J. Paul Boehmer

Larry King

1 ep

David Bowe

Russell Goldstein

1 ep

Adwin Brown

Dennis

1 ep

Kyle Butenhoff

Ron

1 ep

Celestial

Dana

1 ep

Sarah Chang

Emily Soo

1 ep

Bill Chott

MPA President

1 ep

Robert DeSanti

Officer #1

1 ep

Matthew Downs

Officer Melnick

1 ep

Adam Dunnells

White Prisoner

1 ep

Leroy Edwards III

Osvaldo Durruthy

1 ep

Kareem Ferguson

Lemar

1 ep

Britt George

Portage Prison Guard #3

1 ep

John Grady

Barry Goldman

1 ep

Andy Hernandez

Portage Prison Guard #2

1 ep

Jackson Hurst

Stone Phillips

1 ep

Doug Long

Officer #2

1 ep

Verton R. Banks

Larry King

1 ep

Dominic Burgess

John Wayne Gacy

1 ep

Chris Greene

Chaplain Adams

1 ep

Linda Park

Julie Yang

1 ep

Ariella Amar

Checkout Woman

1 ep

Aaron Anastasi

Physician

1 ep

Anias Anozie

Glenda's Grandson

1 ep

Troy Blendell

Roy Ratcliffe

1 ep

Scott Broderick

Warden Jeff Endicott

1 ep

Austin Cauldwell

Rick

1 ep

Grant Davis

Judge Daniel George

1 ep

Patrick Day

Chaplain Berkum

1 ep

Nicole Lynn Evans

Prison Librarian

1 ep

Roslyn Gentle

Coroner

1 ep

Jeff Harms

Jesse Anderson

1 ep

Kiff VandenHeuvel

Frank Currier

1 ep

Jay Jackson

Newscaster

1 ep

Matt Kaminsky

Walter Jacobson

1 ep